Short answer: no, you don’t strictly need one. Plenty of Italian home bakers use the tall paper cases, and a clean coffee tin lined with baking paper will do at a push. But if you’re planning to make panettone more than once, a proper tin makes the whole thing far less stressful, and I’ll explain why.

Why panettone is awkward to bake

Panettone is a rich, buttery, eggy dough that rises upwards a lot. It needs tall, straight sides to climb, or it just slumps out sideways into something closer to a brioche. It also stays soft and fragile when it comes out of the oven. That’s why the traditional trick is to skewer the bottom and hang it upside down to cool, so the crumb doesn’t collapse under its own weight.

So whatever you bake it in has to do two things: hold it up tall while it bakes, and let you get it out without tearing it.

Option 1: paper panettone cases

These are what the bakeries use. They’re cheap, you bake the panettone in them, and you leave the paper on to serve or give as a gift. You can push skewers straight through paper and loaf for hanging upside down.

The downside is that they’re single use and a bit floppy. If your dough is very soft they can bulge, and you’ll want to sit them on a baking tray so they don’t tip over in the oven.

Option 2: a springform panettone tin

This is what I’d go for if you bake every Christmas. The Ibili 826716 panettone mould is a good example. It’s a tall, round, non-stick tin around 16cm across with a springform clip down the side, so it opens up instead of you trying to shake the loaf out.

Going by the Amazon listing, it’s:

  • Springform (removable) design, so the sides release with a clip
  • Non-stick coating for easier release
  • Oven safe and dishwasher safe
  • About 16cm in diameter with tall straight sides

That clip is the whole point. A tall, light, buttery loaf is easy to wreck if you have to tip it out. Opening the side lets you slide it free, and then you can skewer and hang it as normal.

I’d still line it with a strip of baking paper that sticks up above the rim. Panettone dough can rise higher than the tin, and the paper collar gives it something to lean on.

Option 3: improvise

A large, clean tin (the kind posh coffee or chocolate comes in) lined with two layers of baking paper works. So does a deep cake tin with a tall paper collar tied round it. The results are fine but less predictable, and it’s harder to judge the bake time.

Which should you pick?

  • Making one to give away: paper cases. They look the part and the recipient keeps the case.
  • Making it every year: a springform tin like the Ibili. It’s reusable, easy to clean and takes the fear out of unmoulding.
  • Trying it once to see if you like it: improvise with what you’ve got.

Honestly, the tin is a modest bit of kit next to the eggs, butter and candied peel you’re putting in it. If you’ve got the patience to wait out a two-day panettone, it seems daft to risk the whole loaf at the last step. You can check it out here: Ibili panettone springform mould on Amazon UK.